Great Novelists vs. Amateurs: What's the difference?

Posted on 2025-02-28 13:02

The writing style of great novel authors differs from that of amateurs in several key ways, including depth of storytelling, mastery of language, and nuanced character development. Here are some distinguishing factors:

1. Narrative Depth and Complexity

Great Authors: Construct layered, intricate plots that unfold naturally, weaving multiple themes and subplots seamlessly.

Amateurs: May rely on predictable or linear storytelling without depth, leading to a lack of engagement.

"The road goes ever on and on..." — J.R.R. Tolkien
"They walked down the road to see what was ahead." — Amateur Writing

2. Character Development

Great Authors: Create multi-dimensional characters with realistic motivations, internal conflicts, and growth arcs.

Amateurs: Often write flat or stereotypical characters who lack complexity.

"Elizabeth’s spirit sank..." — Jane Austen
"Elizabeth was sad but pretended to be happy." — Amateur Writing

3. Use of Language and Style

Great Authors: Have a distinctive voice, using precise, evocative language that enhances mood, theme, and character.

Amateurs: Might use cliché phrases or lack consistency in tone and voice.

"The world breaks everyone..." — Ernest Hemingway
"Bad things happen, but people learn from them." — Amateur Writing

4. Show, Don’t Tell

Great Authors: Use sensory details, dialogue, and action to reveal emotions and themes subtly.

Amateurs: Tend to over-explain, telling readers what to feel rather than letting them experience it.

"He had one of those rare smiles..." — F. Scott Fitzgerald
"He was charming and friendly." — Amateur Writing

5. Dialogue Realism

Great Authors: Write dialogue that feels natural and drives the plot forward.

Amateurs: Often have characters speak in an unnatural or expository way.

"You never really understand a person..." — Harper Lee
"Try to imagine what it’s like to be someone else." — Amateur Writing

6. Pacing and Structure

Great Authors: Understand how to control pacing, knowing when to slow down for reflection and when to increase tension.

Amateurs: May struggle with erratic pacing—either rushing through or dragging out unnecessary details.

"It was a bright cold day in April..." — George Orwell
"It was April and cold outside." — Amateur Writing

7. Symbolism and Subtext

Great Authors: Weave themes and symbolism organically, allowing deeper meanings to emerge subtly.

Amateurs: Often state themes overtly or fail to integrate them meaningfully.

"Call me Ishmael." — Herman Melville
"My name is Ishmael, and this is my story." — Amateur Writing

8. Editing and Refinement

Great Authors: Revise rigorously, ensuring every word serves a purpose.

Amateurs: May not edit thoroughly, leaving inconsistencies and weak phrasing.

"Mrs. Dalloway said she would buy the flowers herself." — Virginia Woolf
"She decided to buy the flowers instead of having someone else do it." — Amateur Writing

9. Emotional Resonance

Great Authors: Create moments that feel authentic and emotionally impactful.

Amateurs: Might force emotions, leading to melodrama rather than genuine feeling.

"124 was spiteful. Full of a baby’s venom." — Toni Morrison
"The house was haunted by a baby’s ghost. It felt mean." — Amateur Writing

10. Originality and Risk-Taking

Great Authors: Push boundaries, experiment with form, and challenge conventions while maintaining coherence.

Amateurs: May imitate popular styles without injecting a unique perspective.

"Many years later, as he faced the firing squad..." — Gabriel García Márquez
"Colonel Buendía was about to be executed. He thought about his past." — Amateur Writing

Great novelists master both the **art and craft of storytelling**, while amateurs are often still developing these skills.

This post has been viewed 38 times.